In What Can I Hope?

Spiritual Yearning in the Nones and Dones

An illuminated gold sheet folds around a dark opening. Scrolling reveals inscriptions across its curved surfaces.
Inscriptions and sources

Genesis 1:3

יְהִי אוֹר

Biblical Hebrew. From the Leningrad Codex. Vowel points are retained and cantillation marks are omitted.

Unicode/XML Leningrad Codex

John 1:38

Τί ζητεῖτε;

Koine Greek. The question Jesus asks the two disciples who follow him.

Greek Textus Receptus, eBible

Qur’an 94:6

إِنَّ مَعَ ٱلۡعُسۡرِ يُسۡرٗا

Qur’anic Arabic. The complete sixth verse of Sūrat al-Sharḥ, with the reading marks of the cited edition.

Quran.com, Sūrat al-Sharḥ

Bhagavad Gītā 2.47

कर्मण्येवाधिकारस्ते मा फलेषु कदाचन।

Sanskrit in Devanagari. The first half of verse 2.47, ending at the single danda.

IIT Kanpur, Bhagavad Gītā

Heart Sūtra · T 251

色即是空

Classical Chinese. Four characters from Xuanzang’s translation, Taishō volume 8, text 251, page 848c, line 9.

CBETA, Heart Sūtra

Japji Sahib · Ang 1

ਆਦਿ ਸਚੁ ਜੁਗਾਦਿ ਸਚੁ ॥

Gurmukhi script. A line from Guru Nanak’s Japji Sahib on the first ang of the Guru Granth Sahib.

SearchGurbani, Ang 1, line 3

Percy Bysshe Shelley · Prometheus Unbound

to hope till Hope creates

English. A phrase from Demogorgon’s closing speech in Act IV of Shelley’s lyrical drama, published in 1820.

First edition, p. 153

Lu Xun · My Old Home

走的人多了,也便成了路。

Chinese in traditional characters. In the closing paragraph of 故鄉 (1921), the narrator compares hope to a path made by the people who walk it.

Read 故鄉 in Chinese

Where do people turn for meaning and belonging when a religious tradition no longer feels like home?

The inquiry

What stays with us when belief changes?

A person may leave a congregation and still pray with a friend. Another may find the words for a spiritual longing on a pilgrimage, or in a forest. How do we recognize what these experiences share?

We use “Nones” for people who identify with no religion and “Dones” for people who have stepped away from a religious community or tradition. Each study asks where those terms fit and where people use other words for their lives.

Across the studies, one question recurs. When does yearning foster curiosity, humility and care for others, and when can it leave a seeker vulnerable?

Cross-cultural research

How do we compare experiences of longing?

A pilgrimage, a shared silence, a ritual at home. The team begins with how people describe these experiences in their own words, then compares what seeking asks of them.

Three intersecting bands of fine silver wire form an open sphere.
15Team members
24Months of research
6Planned outcomes

October 2026 – September 2028

The work over two years

  1. October 2026 – March 2027

    Conceptual mapping

    Compare how people name longing, describe belonging and understand departure in each setting.

  2. April – September 2027

    Framework development

    Bring the case studies into conversation and test a shared account of yearning, virtue and vulnerability.

  3. October 2027 – March 2028

    Engagement and publication

    Develop journal submissions and accessible materials, and prepare the research for public discussion.

  4. April – September 2028

    Close-out

    Revise the synthesis, bring the book together and complete the final report.

The team

One inquiry, many starting points

Kelly James Clark and Emil Salim lead a team working across philosophy, theology, religious studies and the social sciences. Explore the individual studies, from Quaker prayer to spiritual longing in Mentawai.